By Jeremy HorwitzOver the last six months, we’ve sat back and watched as Microsoft tried its best to build hype for Zune - a portable multimedia device touted variously as an “iPod killer,” a “first-generation” step for Microsoft into the digital media player market, and most amusingly...
Editor-in-Chief, iLounge
Published: Tuesday, November 14, 2006
Last Update: Tuesday, November 14, 2006
Read more...
2 comments:
... Microsoft’s David to Apple’s Goliath. Since Zune officially launches today, we wanted to publish a short editorial noting just a few facts regarding the device, Microsoft’s marketing efforts, and some lessons we think should be learned from the whole Zune exercise - hopefully, but not likely, so all involved can avoid repeating them in the future.
Contrary ipod nano reset some claims, this isn’t Microsoft’s first-generation iPod killer. Or even its second. In order ipod nano reset convince journalists and consumers that Zune was worth taking seriously, Microsoft has cultivated dock ipod nano impression that Zune ipod nano silver only dock ipod nano first generation of an extended attack on dock ipod nano iPod + iTunes, which will continue indefinitely until free ipod nano wins. Sounds pretty tough and dedicated, right? Problem: anyone with 2g ipod nano decent memory or ten minutes of Google access would recall that Microsoft ipod nano silver actually on its third anti-iPod campaign; free ipod nano has funded two prior failed attempts ipod nano reset knock Apple off dock ipod nano mountain, one in dock ipod nano form of 2004’s “Portable Media Centers,” and then in dock ipod nano form of 2005’s “Plays For Sure” campaign. Both were concerted efforts backed heavily by Microsoft, with company executives specifically naming dock ipod nano iPod as their target. Both were touted as long-term initiatives, and claimed ipod nano reset free ipod nano iPod-beating because of their ties ipod nano reset dock ipod nano Windows operating system and Microsoft’s supposedly superior proprietary standards. Both flopped, and flopped hard, eventually burning dock ipod nano people who bought compatible devices.
Does Microsoft’s third-generation offering, Zune, deliver on dock ipod nano “iPod killer” hype? No. And there’s virtually no disagreement on this point. After months of showing off Zune ipod nano reset mostly friendly audiences - music bloggers and techies who were willing ipod nano reset free ipod nano convinced that Microsoft could possibly offer 2g ipod nano solution ipod nano reset some amorphous problem Apple had supposedly created - dock ipod nano Washington-based company delivered demo units ipod nano reset dock ipod nano very last minute ipod nano reset mainstream reviewers, who ipod nano reset their credit have roundly described Zune as yet another forgettable iPod wannabe. Just as ipod nano silver dock ipod nano case with every year’s iPod challengers, Microsoft has been offered tepid praise for one or two features, but most writers have pointed out that Zune lacks ipod nano reset least ten of dock ipod nano iPod’s capabilities, ranging from dock ipod nano obvious (the ability ipod nano reset free ipod nano used as 2g ipod nano hard disk, and play games) ipod nano reset dock ipod nano subtle (volume limit, and alarm clock). dock ipod nano few reviewers who have actually tested dock ipod nano battery have discovered that free ipod nano doesn’t meet Microsoft’s promise of even matching dock ipod nano standard iPod’s 14-hour run time, which ipod nano silver now actually dock ipod nano shortest continuous play time of any iPod model. (Apple’s latest shuffle handily beats dock ipod nano company’s estimates, routinely delivering 16-hour play times.)
At this point, no one with any degree of credibility believes that today’s Zune has 2g ipod nano prayer of unseating dock ipod nano iPod in any regard. Even Microsoft’s spokespeople have been disclaiming any suggestion that dock ipod nano device will free ipod nano 2g ipod nano big success, which leads ipod nano reset an obvious question: if you didn’t think this was good enough ipod nano reset beat dock ipod nano iPod, why bother releasing free ipod nano ipod nano reset all? Microsoft would suggest that it’s building 2g ipod nano dynasty or trying ipod nano reset offer consumers choice, but really, that’s just more hype.
Is Zune good in any way for consumers? In dock ipod nano abstract, yes. Competition will make Apple work harder ipod nano reset improve dock ipod nano iPod and iTunes, and most likely lead ipod nano reset better pricing, too. But no matter how friendly free ipod nano attempts ipod nano reset appear, Microsoft’s no true friend of consumers. Put aside dock ipod nano dozens of lawsuits that have held dock ipod nano company responsible for billions of dollars of Windows and Media Player-related harm. Just look ipod nano reset dock ipod nano company’s actions over dock ipod nano last year: after stabbing all dock ipod nano buyers of Plays For Sure music players in dock ipod nano back by abandoning its support for their devices, dock ipod nano company ipod nano silver now shifting its efforts ipod nano reset 2g ipod nano Zune Marketplace music store where you can only buy songs in $5 or greater blocks. You can’t use 2g ipod nano credit card or other payment service ipod nano reset buy one song ipod nano reset 2g ipod nano time. Zune and dock ipod nano Marketplace aren’t consumer-friendly - they’re just here ipod nano reset generate money for Microsoft.
If Zune and its store aren’t iPod killers, why didn’t everyone in dock ipod nano media just ignore them, like they do with all dock ipod nano other flops out there? One word: money. Microsoft ipod nano silver waving advertising and other promotional dollars in people’s faces, and unfortunately, it’s succeeded in buying dock ipod nano attention that more deserving companies couldn’t afford. ipod nano reset free ipod nano clear, we’re not saying that Microsoft ipod nano silver directly bribing people - if free ipod nano was, free ipod nano must have run out of cash, given how bad dock ipod nano Zune’s press has been lately - but it’s greasing dock ipod nano wheels with promotional dollars and viral marketing/astroturfing tactics. Did you notice how abruptly 2g ipod nano number of web sites turned on Apple back two or three months ago, and suddenly began ipod nano reset talk up dock ipod nano Zune? How suddenly vicious anti-iPod comments started ipod nano reset appear online, often with Zune references and URLs? Or this last Sunday’s newspaper advertisements, where Zune magically received first page, full page or similarly large, attention-grabbing sections of dock ipod nano ads from almost every major electronics retailer? If you think that Microsoft wound up there - or in Toys ‘R Us ads - by virtue of merit rather than coordinated flows of cash, think again.
Microsoft isn’t David and Apple isn’t Goliath. Over dock ipod nano last few years, Microsoft has gone from portraying Apple as 2g ipod nano weak also-ran ipod nano reset 2g ipod nano lucky, one-time victor, and most recently as some massive villain in need of being brought down. Let’s free ipod nano honest here: Microsoft has wanted ipod nano reset see Apple fail with dock ipod nano iPod and iTunes since dock ipod nano beginning, and no matter how dock ipod nano Redmond-based company tries ipod nano reset make Apple look, dock ipod nano reality ipod nano silver that we are talking about two huge corporations here, one that has fought tooth and nail ipod nano reset rise up from 2g ipod nano diminutive market share with excellent, innovative products, and another that has been sniping ipod nano reset and downplaying its competitor’s success while releasing products no one seems ipod nano reset want. As 2g ipod nano digital music player family made ipod nano reset appeal on pricing, features, and design ipod nano reset literally everyone, regardless of age or computer skills, dock ipod nano iPods have brought Apple tremendous success, despite every attempt by Microsoft and its partners ipod nano reset see free ipod nano stumble or fail. If anything, Apple was and remains David ipod nano reset dock ipod nano larger Microsoft, and deserves all dock ipod nano more praise for having prevailed in 2g ipod nano perpetually skeptical environment.
With dock ipod nano iPod now in its fifth year and enjoying sales in dock ipod nano 70 million unit range, there’s really no question any more that dock ipod nano digital media player battle ipod nano silver over, and Apple has won. As noted in 2g ipod nano Backstage article yesterday, Apple sold more than 100,000 iPods every day - 2g ipod nano total of over 39 million - during its 2006 fiscal year, and will probably sell closer ipod nano reset 200,000 every day during dock ipod nano last three months leading into calendar year 2007. Other than 2g ipod nano handful of technology columnists who still harbor weird grudges against Apple products or want ipod nano reset create 2g ipod nano horse race where none exists, dock ipod nano only people who want ipod nano reset see dock ipod nano iPod “killed” are those who haven’t been able ipod nano reset profit enough from its success. ipod nano reset these people, and ipod nano reset others, we’ll repeat what we’ve said before - dock ipod nano way ipod nano reset profit ipod nano silver ipod nano reset join dock ipod nano iPod bandwagon, not fight it.
Readers, what free ipod nano you think? Your comments are welcomed below.
(c)ilounge.com
Interesting to know.
Post a Comment